Vote: Broke’s Backwash Toilet or Biggie’s Bullet Train!
BY RK MISRA
Governments either placate people or subjugate them.The prerogatives of the powerful often override the wishes of the weak.The Gujarat Local Authorities Laws(Amendment) Bill,2009 which makes voting compulsory in elections to local self-government bodies falls in this category.Cleared by Governor O.P.Kohli,it was gazetted by the Gujarat Government on November 5 this year.Thus voting in civic elections is now compulsory in the state by law.But will it be?
A process initiated by
the then chief minister Narendra Modi as part of his brand building
exercise in 2009,the Bill is now the law and the man who set the ball rolling
is now the Prime Minister.However his successor,Anandiben Patel on whom the
responsibility of implementing it rests is now realizing the enormity
of the task at hand.
According to highly
placed sources,the present Gujarat government has no intention of opening
the can of worms that could add to it’s woes and has decided to put things on
hold.”The process of notifying the Bill will take time as all aspects
will have to be studied in detail before it is done”,official sources
said.The fact is that a litigational quagmire awaits it no sooner this is
done.
The Gujarat Local
Authorities Laws(Amendment)Bill,2009 is essentially the brainwave of the
present Prime Minister Narendra Modi,who had then argued that it would
economise the process of local self government elections besides creating
the template for exploring similar avenues for a national exercise.The Bill
was first tabled in the State Assembly in December
2009.Interestingly ,Modi was missing both when the Bill was being debated
and later when it was being voted upon.However,he was most vocal, lashing out
against the then Governor Kamala Beniwal ,for playing partisan politics(UPA was
in power at the Centre).The Governor,on her part, had sent the Bill back for
the Government’s re-consideration.As Modi was wont to do,he re-introduced the
Bill in the State Assembly in 2010, milked it for political mileage for over an
year, and then used his brute majority to get it passed on December
28,2011.Subsequently,it lay with the Governor until Modi assumed charge as
Prime Minister, ignominiously shunted out Beniwal ,and the new Governor cleared
it last month.
A political creature to the core,Modi had linked up compulsory
voting with 50 per cent reservation for women.The then Governor had gone
on record to welcome the reservation for women but made it clear
that compulsory voting and the provision of penalizing a voter for not
doing so was against the spirit of the Constitution and the Election Commission
would never agree to it.She had suggested delinking the two issues but Modi was
not forthcoming and used the issue to the hilt against the Congress and
the UPA government both in the 2012 Vidhan Sabha as well as the 2014 general elections.
Compulsory elections
may not hold much importance for Modi,but compulsory voting for women sure
does.In fact,in a different context, the publicity conscious Prime Minister has
already sent out instructions in Gujarat that the fact of heightened reservation
for women in the police in Gujarat should form the subject of a major advt
blitz countrywide .A hoarding campaign carrying images of Modi and the Gujarat
chief minister is expected to be launched soon.Work has already
begun on it.
The then Governor had
advanced her own arguments for sending the Bill back.Her view was that it
violated Article19(1)(A) of the
Constitution which guaranteed freedom of expression which also included
the right not to vote.Also ,she felt, no provision has been made regarding
the government’s duty of incorporating all eligible voters in the voter’s list,
and distribution of voter’s identity card.Nor was the penal consequences cited,that the voter
will suffer if declared a defaulter for not voting.Interestingly, a
similar Bill was introduced in Parliament by a BJP MP in 2004 but was
rejected after discussion.
There are those who
believe-and I do too- that such ‘luxuries’ of political thought ill suits a
country whose Prime Minister has to issue a national call on such a basic
thing as cleanliness.That Gujarat , a state which is unable to provide
toilets in 5000 pre-primary schools and is straining every
nerve grappling with such and other absolutely basic amenities,should be
thinking of compulsory voting in civic elections sounds like an
absurdity,they say.
Issues,herein,are for
real.Those in Gujarat are fully aware that the bulk of it’s tribal population
migrates from it’s traditional homeland to other parts of the state for
livelihood working as daily wage labourers. Does the popular
government expect these poverty inflicted people to travel back homewards
every time a local election takes place?Or keep returning home for penal
proceedings if they fail to turn up for voting?
The Gujarat
administration is hard put dealing with the legacy of a crowded
timetable of fairs and festivals-agriculture,tourism,garib kaliyan melas,school
enrolment drives,vibrant Gujarat global investment fairs- passed down by
the previous government.Where will it have the time,resources and manpower to
undertake such a mammoth operation as this one which begins from the
grassroots and covers every part of the state?It would be better
if those in power address grassroot issues rather than spend time
building money guzzling memorials to themselves.The Mahatma Mandir in Gujarat-a
convention hall built in the name of Gandhi-
costs over Rs 500 crores and the Statue of Sardar Patel,twice the size
of the statue of liberty ,planned now
on,will incur an expenditure of over Rs 2000 crores.Modi wants history to
remember him for these osmotic projects.The fact,however is,that toilets are
the need of the hour not bullet trains costing over Rs 65,000 crores to build
just to travel from Ahmedabad to Mumbai.which costs
less than a thousand rupees by high speed Duranto today!
Comments
Post a Comment